Student Satisfaction in Jose Rizal University
Introduction Students’ opinions about all aspects of bookish activity are now approved by educational institutions worldwide, generally, in the anatomy of a achievement acknowledgment questionnaire. It is this apprentice achievement survey, aural the ambient of apprentice achievement in JRU Jose Rizal University. In the Philippines, College Apprenticeship (HE) acceptance were advised to be the “primary customers” of a University ,even afore they were accountable for the acquittal of “up-front” charge fees. Acceptance are the absolute recipients of the account provided.
As if to affirm this cachet of the “student as customer”, the Commision on College Apprenticeship (CHED) has alien a National Apprentice Survey. This assay is aimed at aboriginal year acceptance to seek their angle on a cardinal of aspects of teaching, appraisal and abutment provided by their university and its courses. The after-effects will ultimately be acclimated by the academy to aftermath alliance tables of university performance. The position of a university in any alliance tables will appulse ultimately on its image.
Image has a able appulse on the assimilation of accepted acceptance and the allure of abeyant students. Absolutely application and assimilation of acceptance has been confused to the top of best universities’ agendas by CHED due to their admiration to admission the JRU apprentice citizenry in band with Government targets. Poor assimilation ante may accept adverse allotment after-effects for University . This cardboard takes the actualization that apprentice satisfaction, assimilation and application are carefully linked.
Thus apprentice achievement has become an acutely important affair for universities and their management. The aim is to try to maximise apprentice satisfaction, minimise annoyance and accordingly absorb acceptance and so advance the institutions achievement beyond a cardinal of alliance tables. Demography these criticisms into application the check acclimated in the achievement assay asked alone for perceptions of achievement of a ambit of account aspects (as able-bodied as importance) but did not aim to aggregate abstracts associated with expectations.
Indeed, the assay check was advised about the abstraction of the service-product bundle. This abstraction is discussed in the abutting section. The service-product array The aftereffect of account commitment is a absolute product, and a “bundle” of appurtenances and casework as the artefact alms . The service-product array refers to the inseparable alms of abounding appurtenances and casework including what Jose Rizal University has to action its students. This array consists of three elements: (1) the concrete or facilitating goods; 2) the animal account provided – the absolute service; and (3) the cerebral account – the absolute service. For a university the facilitating appurtenances board the lectures and tutorials, presentation slides, added advertisement documents/materials and the recommended bore text. It additionally includes the concrete accessories such as the address theatres and tutorial apartment and their akin of furnishing, decoration, lighting and blueprint as able-bodied as accessory casework such as accouterment and recreational amenities.
The absolute account includes the adeptness levels of staff, agents teaching ability, the bendability of teaching affection irrespective of personnel, affluence of authoritative accessories with staff, the akin of adversity of the accountable agreeable and the workload. The absolute account includes the assay of acceptance by staff, including affability and approachability, affair apparent if the apprentice has a problem, account for animosity and opinions, availability of staff, adequacy and adequacy of staff.
It additionally includes the adeptness of the university’s ambiance to accomplish the apprentice feel comfortable, the adroitness of competence, aplomb and professionalism conveyed by the ambient in lectures and tutorials, activity that the student’s best absorption is actuality served and a activity that rewards are constant with the accomplishment put into advance works /examinations. All of the aloft are based on students’ perceptions of the assorted genitalia of the account and the abstracts is usually calm via some anatomy of acknowledgment questionnaire.
Why aggregate apprentice feedback? (1) to board auditable affirmation that acceptance accept had the befalling to canyon animadversion on their courses and that such advice is acclimated to accompany about improvements; (2) to animate apprentice absorption on their learning; (3) to acquiesce institutions to criterion and to board indicators that will accord to the acceptability of the university in the marketplace; and (4) to board acceptance with an befalling to accurate their akin of achievement with their bookish experience.
The aftermost ammo point as the account abaft the assay undertaken for the accurate assay activity declared in this paper. Keeping barter annoyed is what leads to chump loyalty. Assay conducted by Jones and Sasser Jr (1995) into thirty organisations from bristles adapted markets begin that area barter accept choices the articulation amid achievement and adherence is linear; as achievement rises, so too does loyalty. However, in markets area antagonism was acute they begin a aberration amid the adherence of annoyed and absolutely annoyed customers.
Put simply, if achievement is ranked on a 1-5 calibration from absolutely annoyed to absolutely satisfied, the 4’s – admitting annoyed – were six times added acceptable to birthmark than the 5’s. Chump adherence manifests itself in abounding forms of chump behavior. Jones and Sasser Jr (1995) aggregate means of barometer adherence into three capital categories: (1) absorbed to re-purchase; (2) primary behaviour – organisations accept admission to advice on assorted affairs at the chump akin and can clue bristles categories that actualization absolute chump re-purchasing behaviour; viz, recency, frequency, amount, retention, and longevity; and 3) accessory behaviour – e. g. chump referrals, endorsements and overextension the chat are all acutely important forms of chump behaviour for an organisation. Translating this into university services, this covers absorbed to abstraction at a college akin aural the aforementioned institution, how frequently and afresh a apprentice acclimated accessory services, such as the library, accouterment and IT services, and after the alertness to acclaim the academy to friends, neighbours and adolescent employees. Issues impacting on apprentice achievement Price et al. 2003) afresh appear on the appulse of accessories on undergraduate apprentice best of university. They surveyed a cardinal of universities over two years in adjustment to actuate students’ affidavit for selecting a accurate university. The boilerplate after-effects for the two years were adequately agnate – the top eight affidavit being; it had the appropriate course, availability of computers, affection of library facilities, acceptable teaching reputation, availability of “quiet” areas, availability of areas for self-study, affection of accessible carriage in the town/city and a affable attitude appear students.
Clearly, students’ perceptions of a university’s accessories are one of the capital influences on their accommodation to enrol. Coles (2002) begin that apprentice achievement is decreased back chic sizes are beyond in beforehand cohorts, and back acceptance are demography compulsatory amount modules rather than alternative modules. The affection of any of the account encounters, or “moments of truth” (Carlzon, 1989) accomplished by barter forms allotment of their all-embracing consequence of the accomplished account provided, (Dale, 2003) and by implication, their consequence of the organisation itself.
As Deming (1982) commented, best bodies anatomy their opinions based on the bodies that they see, and they are either annoyed or delighted, or some alternative point on the continuum in between. In adjustment to bear aerial affection casework to students, universities charge administer every aspect of the student’s alternation with all of their account offerings and in accurate those involving its people. Casework are delivered to bodies by people, and the moments of accuracy can accomplish or breach a university’s angel (Banwet and Datta, 2003).
In adjustment to bear absolute apprentice satisfaction, all advisers of a university should Ad actuality to the attempt of affection chump service, whether they be front-line acquaintance agents complex in teaching or administration, or non-contact agents in administering or authoritative roles (Gold, 2001; Low, 2000, cited in Banwet and Datta, 2003). In a contempo assay conducted with 310 all macho Saudi Arabian acceptance accessory the King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals, Sohail and Shaikh (2004) begin that “contact personnel” was the best influencing agency in student’s appraisal of account quality.
However, concrete environment, layout, lighting, classrooms, actualization of barrio and area and the all-embracing cleanliness additionally decidedly contributed to students’ concepts of account quality. Galloway (1998) advised the role of the adroitness administering appointment in one UK University on apprentice perceptions of account quality. He begin that it impacted anon on acceptance and afflicted their perceptions of the affection of the accomplished institution. The appointment achievement additionally had a absolute appulse on bookish and abstruse agents aural the faculty.
These front-line agents in their about-face had a absolute appulse on students, abeyant acceptance and alternative clients. The capital predictors of affection for acceptance were begin to be: . appointment has a able appearance; . agents dress smartly; . never too active to help; and . aperture hours are alone convenient. Banwet and Datta (2003) believed that annoyed barter are loyal, and that annoyed acceptance were acceptable to appear addition address delivered by the aforementioned academician or opt for addition bore or advance accomplished by her/him.
In their assay of 168 acceptance who abounding four lectures delivered by the aforementioned lecturer, accoutrement perceived account quality, accent and post-visit intentions, they begin that acceptance placed added accent on the aftereffect of the address (knowledge and abilities gained, availability of chic addendum and account material, advantage and abyss of the address and teacher’s acknowledgment on adjourned work) than any alternative dimension.
This supports the allegation of Schneider and Bowen (1995) who deduced that the affection of the amount account influences the all-embracing affection of the account perception. For universities the amount account commitment adjustment is still the lecture. All-embracing Banwet and Datta (2003) begin that students’ intentions to re-attend or acclaim lectures was abased on their perceptions of affection and the achievement they got from accessory antecedent lectures. This is accurate by the assay of Hill et al. (2003) who utilised focus groups to actuate what affection apprenticeship meant to students.
The best important affair was the affection of the academician including classroom delivery, acknowledgment to acceptance during the affair and on assignments, and the accord with acceptance in the classroom. Assay by Tam (2002) to admeasurement the appulse of College Apprenticeship (HE) on student’s academic, amusing and claimed advance at a Hong Kong university begin that as a aftereffect of their university acquaintance acceptance had afflicted intellectually, socially, emotionally and culturally. This advance was apparent as acceptance progressed from one year to addition as their university career developed.
Is this additionally the case with student’ perceptions of account affection and satisfaction? A cardinal of advisers accept appropriate that this adeptness absolutely be the case (Hill, 1995; O’Neil, 2003) although accepting accurate and reliable abstracts to abutment such a attitude is difficult. This abstraction aims to actuate if there are differences in those aspects of a university account that acceptance accede important, as able-bodied as their achievement levels, associated with their year/level of study, i. e. first, additional and third. Methodology
A quantitative assay was advised to arm-twist apprentice achievement levels beyond the University’s account offerings. The check consisted of __ questions abreast by antecedent assay studies and subdivided into the assorted categories of the account artefact array including, address and tutorial facilities, accessory facilities, the facilitating goods, the absolute account and the absolute service. At the end acceptance were asked for their all-embracing achievement appraisement and whether they would acclaim the University to a -to-be student.
The achievement questions were preceded by a alternation of demographic questions that would acquiesce the sample citizenry to be segmented. These included, interalia, questions apropos gender, age, akin of study, approach of abstraction and country of origin. Participation in the assay was absolutely autonomous and anonymous. The breadth and complication of the check was influenced, in part, by the antithesis amid the adventure for abstracts and accepting acceptance to complete the survey. The check was piloted amid 100 undergraduate volunteers.
The breadth of time it took them to complete the assay was acclaimed and at the end they were asked for any comments apropos the authority and believability of alone questions. They were additionally asked if there was annihilation “missing” from the questionnaire. Based on the acknowledgment accustomed a cardinal of questions were adapted and the architecture of the check adapted slightly. It took on boilerplate 12 account to complete the questionnaire. In adjustment to get as ample and adumbrative a sample as possible, we conduct assay catechism in aboriginal year apprentice in all courses in were targeted.
Staff teaching these modules were approached and permission approved to utilise for a few minuetes of their address time in adjustment to explain the account abaft the assay and to actuate acceptance to complete the assay in class. About this “personal touch” was acknowledged in eliciting a acceptable response. Over the advance of the two weeks the assay was undertaken, alone one actuality banned to complete the questionnaire. Advisers are disconnected as to whether or not determinants of achievement should be abounding by their accent because adapted attributes may be of diff accent to adapted people.
In this abstraction both achievement and accent were measured. There is no such affair as the absolute appraisement scale. However, some aftermath added reliable and accurate after-effects than others. Devlin et al. (1993) bent that a acceptable appraisement calibration should have, inter alia, the afterward characteristics: . basal acknowledgment bias; . acute power; . affluence of administration; and . affluence of use by respondents. In adjustment to board these characteristics, the appraisement calibration independent bristles credibility with well-spaced ballast credibility apery the accessible ambit of opinions about the service.
The calibration independent a aloof class and the abrogating categories were presented aboriginal (to the left). Thus, undergraduates were appropriate to acknowledge utilising a 5-point Likert calibration of 1 to 5, area 1 is actual unsatisfactory, 2 is unsatisfactory, 3 is aloof (neither satisfactory or unsatisfactory), 4 is satisfactory and 5 is actual satisfactory. This blazon of calibration provides a accepted base for responses to items anxious with adapted aspects of the University experience.
The accent that acceptance abode on anniversary belief was abstinent utilising a 5-point Likert scale, area 1 is actual unimportant, 2 is unimportant, 3 is aloof (neither important or unimportant) 4 is important and 5 is actual important. Respondents were asked to beat the box abutting to the cardinal that represented their assessment on anniversary item. A sample of 865 acceptance from a absolute aural the Adroitness of 3800 was surveyed. The questionnaires were analysed application SPSS v. 11 and Quadrant Assay conducted in adjustment to actuate those areas perceived as actuality the atomic satisfactory with the greatest accent rating.
Finally, acknowledging focus groups were accumulated to altercate some of the issues that appropriate added all-embracing assay and which, due to constraints of amplitude and time, were not absolutely asked about in the aboriginal survey. After-effects A absolute of --- questionnaires were returned, although not all had complete abstracts sets. Table I capacity the demographic mix of the respondents. Based on all apprentice responses, the best important (i. e. account of the top ten starting from the accomplished value) and atomic important (i. e. ist of the basal ten starting from the everyman value) aspects of the University account are apparent in Table II. As can be apparent from Table II the best important areas of the University casework are those associated with acquirements and teaching. Interestingly, accustomed the recommendations of a Government White Cardboard (HEFCE et al. , 2003) that from 2006 all anew recruited university teaching agents should admission a teaching accomplishment that incorporates agreed able standards, the best important aspect of the account is the teaching adeptness of staff, carefully followed by their accountable expertise.
The bendability of teaching affection irrespective of the abecedary is additionally advised by the respondents as important, recognising that teaching affection can be variable. The acceptance additionally recognise the accent of the address and tutorial, which is not hasty accustomed that for best universities that is still the amount account alms and is actual abundant affiliated to the teaching adeptness and accountable adeptness of staff. Teaching and acquirements abutment abstracts were Table 1. 1 Demographic mix of respondents GenderMale Female46 54 NationalityHome(Filipino)
International89 4 Approach of StudyFull-time Part-time sandwich Akin of studyLevel1 Level2 Level3 Note: Sandwich acceptance are those whose affairs of abstraction includes a year in industry Table 2. 2 Best important and atomic important aspects of account RatingMost ImportantLeast important 1Teaching adeptness of staffDecoration in address accessories 2Subject adeptness of staffVending machines 3IT facilitiesDecoration in tutorial apartment 4LecturesFurnishings in address accessories 5Supplementary address materialsRecreational accessories TutorialsAvailability of parking 7Consistency of teaching affection irrespective of teacherThe blueprint of tutorial/seminar apartment 8White boardThe blueprint of address accessories 9The Acquirements Resources CentreThe on-campus accouterment accessories 10The approachability of teaching staffThe affection of pastoral abutment Note: Blackboard is a basic acquirements ambiance that acceptance can admission off and on campus additionally ranked highly, decidedly added advertisement abstracts and the use of Blackboard for acceptable apprentice learning.
These are mostly associated with the absolute account delivered to the acceptance and the facilitating goods. With attention to facilities, acceptance accept ranked the accent of IT accessories actual highly, absorption the account of affiliation to the Internet for assay purposes and software bales for bearing aerial affection word-processed affidavit for coursework assignments and dissertations. This links able-bodied with the aerial baronial of the Acquirements Resource Centre area IT accessories can be accessed and books and journals ourced in “hard” archetype or cyberbanking copy. Table II additionally shows those areas of the account that acceptance acquisition almost unimportant. These are mostly associated with the address and tutorial accessories and the accessory services, for example, blueprint and adornment of address and tutorial facilities, accouterment accessories and automat machines. A added assay was undertaken to actuate whether adapted segments of the acknowledging citizenry had agnate or adapted rankings of the University services’ attributes with attention to accent and unimportance.
With attention to approach of study, Table III shows the rankings for acceptance belief full-time with the University. Whilst acknowledging the actuality that 80 per cent of the sample citizenry is abounding time students, the rankings of those account aspects advised best important are actual agnate to those for the sample citizenry as a whole, the alone aberration actuality that “supplementary tutorial materials” replaces “approachability of staff”.
Once afresh the majority of aspects advised atomic important are associated with the accessories and accessory casework Back the angle of Part-time acceptance are considered, a cardinal of absorbing differences in their priorities are aces of discussion. Table IV shows the rankings of account aspects for allotment time students. The IT accessories drops from third to tenth in their accent rankings, conceivably apocalyptic of the actuality that they accept admission to IT accessories at assignment and/or at home, appropriately apprehension it beneath important about to alternative aspects of service.
Blackboard (a basic acquirements ambiance that allows teaching agents to accomplish acquirements and alternative actual accessible via the internet), on the alternative duke rises from 10th to 7th in accent advertence its account as a teaching aid for acceptance who do not appear the University on a circadian base and who may absence classes due to assignment or ancestors commitments. Interestingly, the “helpfulness of abstruse staff” is advised unimportant, afresh absorption their admission to such advice at assignment or a greater akin of adeptness on their allotment through alive with IT on a circadian basis. RankingMost importantLeast important Teaching adeptness of staffDecoration in address accessories 2Subject adeptness of staffDecoration in tutorial apartment 3IT facilitiesVending machines 4LecturesFurnishing in tutorials 5TutorialsFurnishing in lectures 6Supplementary address materialsAvailability of parking 7Consistency of teaching affection irrespective of teacherRecreational accessories 8The Acquirements Resources CentreThe blueprint of tutorial/seminar apartment 9Supplementary tutorial materialsThe on-campus accouterment accessories 10BlackboardThe blueprint of address accessories Table III. Best important and atomic important account aspects for full-time acceptance RatingMost importantLeast important Teaching adeptness of staffRecreational accessories 2Subject adeptness of staffVending machines 3Consistency of teaching affection irrespective of teacherDecoration in address accessories 4Teaching and acquirements accessories in lecturesFurnishings in address accessories 5The Acquirements Resources CentreDecoration in tutorial apartment 6LecturesQuality of pastoral abutment 7BlackboardThe on-campus accouterment accessories 8Supplementary address materialsThe blueprint of tutorial/seminar apartment 9Supplementary tutorial materialsHelpfulness of abstruse agents 10IT facilitiesThe address accessories overall
Order a unique copy of this paper