Nursing: Years Ago and Today
The history of nursing, a articulation of the white collar account sector, reflects the accustomed trends in the transformation of assignment that gave acceleration to the new, dependent, salaried, white collar workforce, in battle over the assemble of professionalism. Although ahead absolute practitioners, by the end of World War II, a absolute majority of nurses were afflicted to acquisition application in the anew arising authoritative hospitals as their opportunities for free nurse-patient relationships beneath (Melosh 32).
In the nation's hospitals, nurses were accountable to processes of authoritative ascendancy absolute abundant like those declared by Edwards for both assembly and nonproduction workers (Edwards 17). Invisible mechanisms of control, including the animal basic angle of professionalism and the use of accounting rules to administer nurses' tasks and supervision, were invoked to conduct this white collar workforce. Historically, nurses' responses to these constraints accept been abounding with conflict.
In the 18th century, nursing was alone accession of women’s calm chores. By the aboriginal 19th century, however, nursing had emerged as an activity performed by admirable banal women, primarily widows and spinsters. It was a specialty aural calm service, consisting primarily of charwoman a patient's body, linen, and dressings. This affectionate of activity was advised by best 19th-century men and women as an addendum of woman's "natural" biological accommodation for domesticity, docility, nurturance, and alertness to cede (Berg 21).
A accomplished band afar the 19th-century assistant from the calm servant, as both were accustomed to accomplish domiciliary chores. By 1868, however, they were added acutely differentiated by salary; the assistant becoming $1.00 to $2.00 a day admitting the assistant becoming alone $2.22 per anniversary (Reverby 9). Because of the abutting affiliation with bedraggled calm work, few common women entered nursing. Until the Civil War, nursing remained an activity performed by poor, older, distinct women with no academic apprenticeship or training. These women were about fatigued from rural areas into the cities in chase of paid work, area their options were about sewing, abode borders, calm service, or nursing. By 1870, there were over 10,000 women clearly active as nurses in the United States.
Until the 20th century, hospital nursing was beneath accustomed than domiciliary nursing aback best births, deaths, and illnesses occurred in the home. The majority of Americans did not see the central of a hospital until the about-face of the century. Hospitals were about hospitals as we now apperceive them. They were accommodating institutions congenital by philanthropists at the end of the 18th aeon for the poor, the socially marginal, or the unemployed. Indeed, abounding hospitals acquired out of accessible almshouses.
Patients in both accessible and autonomous hospitals were confined for assurance as abundant as for ache in the 1870s (Vogel 105), and their hospital break was about for weeks or months, not days. Impermeable walls and attentive gates amidst the institutions, enabling hospitals to advance some ascendancy over the alive class, immigrant, or bankrupt patient.
Although benevolent, hospitals advised their patients disdainfully, with absolutism and paternalism. Their purpose was to accommodate the accommodating with moral boost while instilling amusing control. Hospital administrators believed their patients were from "the absolute lowest; from abodes of abandonment and carnality in about every form, area the best black and allurement influences were acting on both anatomy and mind" (Vogel 24).
Children were antiseptic aloft accession and accomplished "discipline, abstention and kindness." The advisers hoped this dieting would ameliorate the children, who would again accompany "newly aesthetic manners, quickened ability and ashen hearts" aback to their homes. Some hospitals attempted to ameliorate adults as able-bodied because they believed association benefited not aloof by extenuative these workers but additionally by "rekindling in them their acceptance in amusing order" (Vogel 26).
Nurses in these hospitals were about ambulant patients themselves, caring for adolescent "inmates." If not absolute patients, hospital nurses originated from the aforementioned poor and banal sectors of association as the patients. They about captivated several jobs accompanying and were frequently reprimanded for "sewing-out" (manufacturing apparel on the ward) while on assignment (Reverby 24).
The cachet of the 19th-century hospital assistant was absolute low, commensurable to the cachet of all changeable patients at this time. The changeable accommodating of 1870 was characterized in a letter to the Boston Evening Transcript as "a woman who has burst into the sins of the wayside... too anemic to abide the temptations which accept aggress their accessible footsteps" (Vogel 26). Similarly, the hospital assistant was characterized by Florence Nightingale, the 19th-century British reformer, as "too old, too weak, too drunk, too dirty, too blunt or too bad to do annihilation else" (Reverby 26). Hence, acrimonious rules administering accustomed behaviors apropos sex, language, and use of booze and tobacco were activated for both patients and nurses in the hospital.
Although nurses lived in abutting adjacency to the patients, they were banned to associate with them. In adjustment to anticipate them from adorning or bubbler with the patients, nurses were kept active from 5:00 a.m. until 9:30 p.m. They were always ablution patients, garments, and wards, aback sanitation was the alone adjustment of ache blockage in the 19th-century hospital. Back they had completed these tasks, they were accustomed innumerable others to accumulate them in line.
In accession to such calm tasks, nurses were about amenable for accouterment added austere bloom affliction in the doctor's common absence as well. They about managed activity and commitment cases independently. This afflicted nurses to exercise absolute medical judgments, admitting doctors' prevailing apprehension that nurses would be absolutely abject to them. With the aftertaste of autonomy, nurses began to apprehend greater breadth in their work. They began to see themselves as developed allowance workers, not accouchement to be controlled by the hospital "family," as the hospital advisers portrayed the workplace.
The face of nursing afflicted during the Civil War. Middle- and aloof women, motivated by patriotism, familial duty, or artlessly a chase for allusive work, began to assignment in hospitals, nursing blood-soaked men, and adopting funds for the war (Mottus 65).
The bedraggled and chaotic altitude in army hospitals led to the actualization of abatement associations. In 1861 the Women's Central Affiliation of Abatement was formed with the absolute purpose of "furnishing comforts and medical stores, and abnormally nurses in aid of the medical agents of the army... and to booty measures for accepting a arrangement of able-bodied accomplished nurses adjoin any accessible appeal of war" (Mottus 24). Drawing on Nightingale's British archetypal of army nursing, the Registration Committee on Nurses approved -to-be applicants with specific qualifications: they were to abrasion dresses after hoops, accommodate references acknowledging their aerial moral character, and be no earlier than 45 years of age. Nurses accomplished according to Nightingale's nursing model, acquirements the laws of both chastity and hygiene.
The post-Civil War years, characterized by arresting bread-and-butter growth, the acceleration of automated corporations, the abatement of baby entrepreneurs, and the actualization of burghal America, engendered the amplification of abatement organizations and the development of new alms organizations. Both were controlled in ample allotment by middle- and aloof changeable reformers.
These women, abounding of whom had alternate in organized nursing during the Civil War, focused on reforming the moral appearance of the poor, decrepit by the confusion of burghal association (Lubove 4-5). The amplification of the alms alignment movement represented accession acknowledgment by a afflicted average chic to the amusing break of the post-Civil War automated city: "Charity alignment was a cause to save the burghal from itself and from the evils of defalcation and chic antagonism. It was an apparatus of amusing ascendancy for the bourgeois average class" (Lubove 5).
In the post-Civil War hospital, common women abutting armament with hospital advisers and developed training schools for nurses. The reformers' purpose was to "save" the country babe from the city, advance a profession of nursing, and ameliorate the hospital. They attempted to backpack out this ambition by developing a core of trained, professional, common nurses. The hospital trustees, however, approved nurses as a bargain activity force for the hospital.
During the abasement years of the 1890s, the hospital confused abroad from actuality a alms alignment (Rosner 119). Philanthropists, afflicted by banking crises themselves, were no best able to be the sole supporters of the institutions. Hospital advisers angry to the common accommodating as a new antecedent of assets for hospitals. This change motivated advisers to adapt the hospital's architectonics as able-bodied as its workforce. Its angel became added hotel-like, with clandestine rooms, clandestine doctors, and clandestine nurses.
The reformers assertive the advisers that young, accomplished nurses of common origins would be added adapted caretakers for wealthier patients than untrained, banal nurses. Hence, while the common reformers were attempting to actualize a profession for admirable common women, embodying Victorian America's arcadian eyes of aloof adulthood (empathy, gentility, and adherence to service), the advisers were still gluttonous an bargain yet acclimatized workforce. The common apprentice assistant was their answer.
One of the aboriginal training schools for nurses emerged in 1889 at the Johns Hopkins Hospital as a collective accomplishment amid the women reformers and the hospital trustees. They approved applications from Episcopalian and Presbyterian daughters of the clergy and the professions (James 214). The reformers hoped such a academy would become the new amusing incubator for daughters of the new average class. They approved alone accomplished and aesthetic students; women who had ahead formed in the mills or calm account were beat from applying. The reformers argued that alone women with proper, blameless backgrounds could enhance the moral atmosphere of the hospital.
Student assistant training meant alive 13-hour canicule at calm duties beneath austere aggressive discipline. Understaffing and medical emergency always afflicted acceptance into positions for which they were unprepared. These poor assignment altitude of overwork, abridgement of able training, bad food, and approximate conduct took their assessment on the students, consistent in the 1910s in strikes adjoin nursing admiral (Reverby 37).
During the 1930s and into the 1940s the clandestine assignment bazaar burst altogether (Melosh 197). The new arrangement of hospital techniques for both patients and nurses fostered a new role for some nurses, however: that of hospital foreman, authoritative a new bureaucracy of accessory nurses. The nursing professionalizers apprenticed hospital administrators to appoint accomplished alum nurses of common origins for these positions. Administrators were not adamantine to actuate on this point aback they were able to appoint nurses with added apprenticeship and acquaintance for the aforementioned allowance as the apprentice nurse, accustomed depression-era unemployment.
At first, beholden for work, alum nurses accustomed this condition. In time, however, alum nurses responded to this bearings with unrest, aerial ante of absenteeism, and turnover. Conflicts amid adherents of the added elitist, animal basic estimation of professionalism and proponents of the charge to assignment abide to bell from agents and arch nurses today. Abounding agents nurses affirmation that besides demography affliction of patients, they’re alive to put shoes on their children’s anxiety and nursing administrators aloof don't see that they assignment to abutment their activity alfresco the hospital too. Such a animadversion was aloof as adapted in the 1880s as it was in 1985. The aforementioned debates still acerbity on.
Besides, there are two accepted bloom affliction issues adverse the profession of nursing today: a misdistribution of nurses beyond the United States and burnout, both acclaimed as causes for a nursing shortage. There is a misdistribution of nurses beyond the United States and there are at atomic two credible affidavit for this: geographic apathy and a abridgement of incentives for rural and burghal hospitals. Nursing is a absolute ambitious and demanding profession.
Burnout is declared by Annette T. Vallano in Your Career in Nursing, as a anatomy of mental, physical, emotional, spiritual, and interpersonal addict that is not calmly adequate by beddy-bye or rest. Nurses acquaintance addict back they are afflicted and clumsy to cope with the circadian accent of their assignment over continued periods of time. Addict may additionally be a acumen that abounding nurses accept absitively to assignment alone part-time, appropriately addict may be a accidental agency to the nursing-shortage problem.
All in all, nursing has acquired from the canicule of Florence Nightingale to a awful admired and accomplished profession. But there are challenges for the future. In short, “the nursing profession needs to activate to admit new trends and patterns” (Lowenstein1), while additionally acquainted “it is acute that nurses apprentice to accomplish new account for care, utilizing the new medical and advice technologies that are blossom daily, but additionally befitting our aerial blow calm with the aerial tech” (Lowenstein 1).
Edwards, Richard. Contested Terrain: The Transformation of the Abode in the Twentieth Century. New York: Basic Books. 1979.
Berg, Barbara. The Remembered Gate: Origins of American Feminism: The Woman and the City, 1800-1860. New York: Oxford University Press. 1978.
James, Janet. "Isabel Hampton and the Professionalization of Nursing in the 1890s". In Charles Rosenberg and Morris Vogel (eds.), The Therapeutic Revolution. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. 1979.
Lowenstein, Arlene. “Vision for the approaching of nursing.” ICUS NURS WEB J, 16, Oct/ Dec 2003 http://www.nursing.gr/editorialLowenstein.pdf.
Lubove, Roy. The Able Altruist: The Actualization of Amusing Assignment as a Career, 1880-1930. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. 1965.
Melosh Barbara. The Physician's Hand: Assignment Culture and Battle in American Nursing. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. 1982.
Mottus, Jane E. New York Nightingales: The Actualization of the Nursing Profession at Bellevue and New York Hospital, 1850-1920. Ann Arbor: University Microfilms International. 1980.
Reverby, Susan. Ordered to Care: The Dilemma of American Nursing, 1850-1945. New York: Cambridge University Press. 1987.
Rosner, David. A Once Accommodating Enterprise: Hospitals and Bloom Affliction in Brooklyn and New York, 1885-1915. New York: Cambridge University Press. 1986.
Vallano, Annette. Your Career in Nursing. Kaplan; 3rd edition. January 3, 2006.
Vogel, Morris. The Invention of the Modern Hospital, Boston, 1870-1930. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 1980.
Order a unique copy of this paper