Case Study Housing Bubble and Its Burst
Case Abstraction Question 1: Explain the account of the apartment balloon and its access in the mid-2000s. To what admeasurement is this botheration the aftereffect of ethical failure?
No distinct account can absolutely explain the crisis but, in my opinion, the two above bases were legislation that answer homeownership and subprime mortgages. To absolutely accept the ambiance that spawned the apartment bubble, we’ll accept to biking aback to the 1930s, back the country was in the bosom of the Great Depression.
During this time frame, homeownership represented alone about 40 percent of U.S. households (Thompson, Peteraf, Gamble, Strickland, 2012, p. c-423). Following astringent mortgage bazaar disruptions, boundless foreclosures, and biconcave homeownership rates, the government created the Federal Apartment Administration (FHA), Fannie Mae, the Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB), and several decades after Freddie Mac to advice advance defended and acceptable homeownership for the approaching bearing of Americans (Reforming America’s Apartment Finance Market, A Report to Congress, 2011, P. 5).
A Subprime Mortgage is a blazon of mortgage that is commonly fabricated out to borrowers with lower acclaim ratings; a accepted mortgage is not offered because the lender angle the borrower as accepting a larger-than-average accident of behind on the loan; lending institutions generally allegation absorption on subprime mortgages at a amount that is college in adjustment to atone themselves for accustomed added risk, as authentic by Investopedia. com, 2013. In 1994, subprime mortgages represented about 6 percent of absolute mortgage loans originated but by 2005 the allotment grew to 37. (Thomson et al. , 2012). Private firms like Countrywide, and others, issued added than 84 percent of the subprime mortgages in 2006 (Swift, 2011). Fast-forward to the 2000s and the furnishings of federal legislation over 60 years added homeownership to about 70 percent (Thomson et al. , 2012) accompanying with an access of subprime mortgages, and acknowledgment of home ethics resulted in the apartment bubble.
Housing Balloon Burst
As there are several factors that created the bubble, there are aloof as abounding that were amenable for its burst.
The best cogent factors were the abolition of a above basic of the Glass-Steagall Act and a attenuated apartment market. First, let's attending at the Glass-Steagall Act. One of the apparatus in the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 afar advance (brokerage) and bartering cyberbanking activities (investopedia. com, 2009). The article assured that banks would be accustomed to booty deposits and accomplish loans, brokers would be accustomed to accede and advertise securities, but no close would be accustomed to do both due to the conflicts of absorption and risks to insured deposits (Rickards, 2012). In 1999, President Bill Clinton and Republicans led by Sen.
Phil Gramm repealed allotment of the Glass-Steagall Act, removing barriers that banned any one academy from acting as any combination, at the bidding of big banks (Rickards, 2012). Secondly, the U. S. abridgement began to weaken, with crumbling appeal for housing, which acquired home prices to collapse and acknowledgment in home prices came to an end, and in best cases abandoning (Thompson et al. , 2012). Homeowners, investors, and banking institutions did not accept abundant basic acknowledging their investments to blot the consistent losses (Reforming America’s Apartment Finance Market, A Report to Congress, 2011, P. ). Homeowners were faced with foreclosure back they absent assets during the bread-and-butter arrest or apparent their acquittal on Adjustable Amount Mortgages (ARMs) acceleration to a point of unaffordability (Thompson et al. , 2012). In 2008, acclaim markets froze. Our nation's banking arrangement – which had outgrown and outmaneuvered a authoritative framework abundantly advised in the 1930s – was apprenticed to the border of collapse. Millions of Americans absent their jobs, families absent their homes, and baby businesses shut bottomward (Reforming America’s Apartment Finance Market, A Report to Congress, 2011, P. 5).
Case Abstraction Question 2: Evaluate Countrywide’s role in the subprime mortgage debacle. Was the company’s conduct bent or illegal? Countrywide’s Role From 2005 to 2007, Civic was the arch subprime lender in the country arising $97. 2 billion in subprime mortgages (Bloomberg Business Week, 2009) but alone led in bazaar allotment by 2 percent. The basal 16 subprime mortgage-issuing firms accounted for $363. 5 billion in mortgages (reference blueprint 1). Civic was amenable for 10 percent of a $1 abundance problem. Conduct Bent or Actionable Civic practices were illegal.
Countrywide was answerable with bloodthirsty lending practices (Thompson et al. , 2012) and after accomplished a multi-state adjustment for $8. 68 billion (Huffman, 2008). “Countrywide’s lending practices angry the American dream into a daydream for tens of bags of families by putting them into loans they couldn’t accept and ultimately couldn’t afford,” said Attorney General Edmund G. Brown Jr., a co-leader of the negotiations for the states (Huffman, 2008). The civic adjustment became the better bloodthirsty lending adjustment in history, dwarfing the civic $484 actor adjustment (Huffman, 2008).
Case Abstraction Question 3: Using this case as an example, who allowances and who gets aching back a aggregation engages in bent or socially capricious behavior? In the long-term, no one allowances from this behavior. In this case study, the companies, shareholders, consumers, and the all-around abridgement all suffered from the capricious behavior of abounding in the banking sector. Between June 2007 and November 2008, Americans absent added than a division of their net account (Wikipedia. org, 2013). Absolute retirement assets alone by 22 percent, from $10. 3 abundance in 2006 to $8 abundance in mid-2008 (Wikipedia. org, 2013).
As with best bent or capricious accumulated behavior, there are no abiding winners.
Denning, S. (2001). Lest We Forget: Why We Had a Banking Crisis. Forbes. Retrieve from: http://www. forbes. com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/22/5086/
Huffman, M. (2008). Civic Settles Bloodthirsty Lending Charges for $8. 68 Billion. Consumer Affairs. Retrieved from: http://www. consumeraffairs. com/news04/2008/10/ countrywide_settlement. html
Investopedia. (2013). Definition of Apartment Bubble. Retrieved from: http://www. investopedia. com/terms/h/housing_bubble. asp#axzz2NRrhirhT
Rickards, J. (2012). Abolition of Glass-Steagall Acquired the Banking Crisis. Bread-and-butter Intelligence. Retrieved from: http://www. usnews. com/opinion/blogs/economic- intelligence/2012/08/27/repeal-of-glass-steagall-caused-the-financial-crisis
The Department of the Treasury. (2011). Reforming America’s Apartment Finance Markets, A Report to Congress. Retrieved from: http://www. treasury. gov/initiatives/Documents/ Reforming%20America's%20Housing%20Finance%20Market. pdf
Thompson, A., Peteraf, M., Gamble, J., Strickland III, A. (2012). Crafting & Executing Strategy, The Quest for Competitive Advantage. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Order a unique copy of this paper